Kathaarian wrote:
Adveser wrote:
crast wrote:
Adveser wrote:
crast wrote:
Adveser wrote:
Again, I've only heard a handful or two of songs on Youtube or from promos other than Alien and frankly every album might as well be a new band the way most acts are.
Hahaha
So you're critiquing his production based on youtube videos. Brilliant.
.:crast:.
I find it equally hilarious you think production can't be heard despite the sound quality. Everyone knows what artifacts and inaccuracies are in a low quality file and wouldn't make a judgment based on them either. It's irrelevant. That isn't even the case here as clarified later on the thread.
I know production well enough...
.:crast:.
Bullshit.
The man is a member of one of the most famous bands in melodic death metal and released 3 albums you fucking twat! And what have you done that put you on that fucking high horse?
Recorded Hundreds of hours of live bands in a three year period. Mixed and Mastered those recordings as well. I don't keep copies of old stuff, so who knows if these still exist.
Quit jobs outright because they stopped me for recording bands for free. Quit jobs that were stressful for my voice. Almost was homeless a number of times. Thankfully my landlord was a rich casket salesman that retired and didn't need the money. Still starved half the time anyway.
Written more songs than most working bands. I put the number between 50-100, all complete. Had no way to record my own stuff for years so the moment passed on most of them. Still have about 20 solid songs I can remember in the vault just waiting for the financing to come through or I meet the right people who have said money or equipment.
Mastered more albums for free than I care to remember by awful bands just so I could learn.
Have a degree in electronics engineering and have invented a few devices of my own with working schematics critiqued by a PHD electromagnetic engineer as being technically proficient. Nothing fancy, good stuff I can use on my voice some day.
Spent over 4 hours a day on average reading production books and have tested and found my own way about the studio as result. Have read dozens of books and applied the concepts within. This is always in my mind no matter what. I can't hear a jingle on TV without figuring out how it was recorded, where the roll-off is, ect. This is my obsession that consumes me at all times. I flat out demand more knowledge and will beg borrow and steal to get it.
Has perfect pitch, intensive ear training, intensive training in critical listening.
I could list a thousand other things, but why bother. You guys will still think Rick Rubin is great even though he is a hack. Knowledge may be power, but not in this bullshit filled industry.
I'm 25. How many 25 year old producer's have you heard of? When people are my age they are usually still getting coffee for people and dreaming of touching the mixing board one day. If they can find a studio that wants free help.
I'm saying the guy hasn't spent the last decade strictly being a producer and sound engineer and spending more time than a doctor educating himself on the subject. Sound is subjective and no matter how good someone is at producing, I still reserve the right to say their production sucks if it doesn't meet my tastes. I have never in any way called into the question other producer's technical credibility, just their artistic ability and writing songs that aren't very moving is an artistic flaw.