Black/Death/Thrash Voting Discussion Thread

DevotedWalnut · **Posted:** Wed Dec 24, 2008 5:07 am

I don't know if that was a joke, or you being serious. But it sure was funny.

belowthelights · **Joined:** Tue Mar 18, 2008 11:10 pm **Posts:** 780

noodles wrote:

on a more important note than what genre CoF are, why the fuck are any of you putting them in a top albums of the year list. fuck off posers!!

hahahaha this is truth.

Kathaarian · **Posted:** Thu Dec 25, 2008 2:35 am

I have to put DsO - Chaining the Katechon somewhere so I put it in my bm list. It's not an album but that doesn't matter right? It is part of a split album after all.

TheMetalWarrior316 · **Joined:** Thu Sep 28, 2006 11:01 am **Posts:** 646

traptunderice wrote:

unreal wrote:

jep, move venom. Let cof stay.

I really can't see how anyone could compare CoF to Krallice, DsO, Xasthur, Leviathan or Nachtmystium?

Do you mean this band: www.myspace.com/nachtmystium ? And this is for you Black Metal and COF not? I'm hearing in Nachtmystium more other musical styles than in Godspeed on the devil's thunder. Rock, Punk, Thrash... it's more or less as "true" as COF on Godspeed are...

And think about this quote:

The_Voice wrote:

[...]bands can sound different even if they play the same genre, you know why? because theyre different bands, thats no reason to start giving genres to every band out there that sounds different or you will end up with a lot of meaningless and useless labels dont you think?

And if I can remember correctly, someone during the infamous COF discussion said that Venom were Black Metal, because they are raw and simple or something like this.

If I I would take away all Bands that are not true enough, there would only be Satyricon left - and for some, even they are not more Black Metal... :lame:

PS.: E.G. Aura Noir is for me Old School Black Metal.

TheMetalWarrior316 · **Joined:** Thu Sep 28, 2006 11:01 am **Posts:** 646

Ok, you guys won. I will remove everything from the Black Metal vote, that's not true norwegian Black Metal. And don't cry about the result.

Ness · **Posted:** Thu Dec 25, 2008 3:39 pm

TheMetalWarrior316 wrote:

Ok, you guys won. I will remove everything from the Black Metal vote, that's not true norwegian Black Metal. And don't cry about the result.

Lol!!

belowthelights · **Joined:** Tue Mar 18, 2008 11:10 pm **Posts:** 780

Kathaarian wrote:

I have to put DsO - Chaining the Katechon somewhere so I put it in my bm list. It's not an album but that doesn't matter right? It is part of a split album after all.

this is a good question. its only a 22min ep so I'm not sure if it qualifies for the list. If so it would easily be my number 1 bm for this year, simply unbelievable.

traptunderice · **Posted:** Thu Dec 25, 2008 8:08 pm

Yeah, new Nachtymystium is probably a bad example but albums like Demise and their debut were definitely straight BM.

Venom isn't black metal. They influenced black metal and extreme metal as a whole though. Aura Noir is blackened thrash and leans more towards the thrash.

DsO's is just an EP. I don't see why it can't go here.

TheMetalWarrior316 · **Joined:** Thu Sep 28, 2006 11:01 am **Posts:** 646

Old School Black Metal IS old school thrash/heavy metal with satanic lyrics/content.

And I never would put Aura Noir on the same page as Metallica or Megadeth. But the same goes for early Sodom, Venom, Hellhammer, Bathory and very early Slayer. Everything that fit's on this sampler: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenriz_Pre ... lack_Metal

doublewhat · **Posted:** Sat Dec 27, 2008 1:50 am

Goat wrote:

TheMetalWarrior316 wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Bullet for my valentine isn't fucking thrash..

And it's not avant garde or something strange. If you would listen to it, you would recognize, that Scream Aim Fire is 80% Bay Area Thrash Metal.

80%?!

Let's put Metalcore in with 'other', people.

I would group them with Shadows Fall. Not as intense and more melodic. Like a balance between Killswitch Engage, Shadows Fall, Avenged Sevenfold and All That Remains. The song writing is better than trivium. There is alot of thrash and eighties riffs and solos mixed with melodic metalcore verses and choruses. I just stick BFMV with the rest of the NWOAHM bands.

traptunderice · **Posted:** Sat Dec 27, 2008 5:01 am

doublewhat wrote:

Goat wrote:

TheMetalWarrior316 wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Bullet for my valentine isn't fucking thrash..

And it's not avant garde or something strange. If you would listen to it, you would recognize, that Scream Aim Fire is 80% Bay Area Thrash Metal.

80%?!

Let's put Metalcore in with 'other', people.

I would group them with Shadows Fall. Not as intense and more melodic. Like a balance between Killswitch Engage, Shadows Fall, Avenged Sevenfold and All That Remains. The song writing is better than trivium. There is alot of thrash and eighties riffs and solos mixed with melodic metalcore verses and choruses. I just stick BFMV with the rest of the NWOAHM bands.

Yeah, in the "other" section.

Rhys · **Posted:** Fri Jan 02, 2009 6:58 pm

Kathaarian wrote:

I have to put DsO - Chaining the Katechon somewhere so I put it in my bm list. It's not an album but that doesn't matter right? It is part of a split album after all.

Technically I don't think it should be included, but since practically everyone has voted for it, and since it would cause massive drama levels, who cares :cool:

Also it's fucking quality and deserves awards.

Metal Reviews

Black/Death/Thrash Voting Discussion Thread

Who is online