MetalWizard wrote:
The_Voice and Radagast:
I hope you're both able to overcome your hearing disability soon. If you two are trying to insinuate that the material on Twisted Sister's "Stay Hungry", "Come Out and Play", and "Love Is For Suckers" is better than the material on Bullet For My Valentine's "Poison" you're way off. Those guys in TS couldn't begin to dream of playing music like that. This is in no way a defense based on a biased opinion. I'm not a BFMV advocate at all. I've heard all the CD's in question though and seen these bands live. I've been listening to and playing metal for 23 years. BFMV blows TS away hands down.
Twisted Sister is a joke. A mere mockery of the genre. They were everything that was awrong with metal in the 80's and today. That Christmas CD was dreadful.
Firstly: "Those guys in TS couldn't begin to dream of playing music like that."
Eddie Ojeda and AJ Pero could blow anyone from BFMV out of the water as musicians, so forget about that line of argument right away.
With regards to: "Twisted Sister is a joke. A mere mockery of the genre. They were everything that was awrong with metal in the 80's and today."
Are you taking the piss? Twisted Sister certainly made a more accessible version Metal. No one's denying this. They also played some straight-up traditional and fairly aggressive metal. You mentioned Stay Hungry and Come Out and Play. Have you heard Under the Blade? Jeez, Burn in Hell is on Stay Hungry. Are you seriously suggesting songs like that are "everything that was wrong with metal"? To file TS with the glam rock bands of the 80s smacks of ignorance.
Bullet For My Valentine, on the other hand, spent nearly 10 years as a band playing Metallica and Nirvana covers before metalcore became popular and they got themselves some slick new haircuts and clothes and started writing songs about hating their ex-girlfriends. They are everything that's wrong with metal
today. Get-rich-quick scenesters of the absolute lowest order.
For the record - Love is For Suckers isn't a real Twisted Sister album. It was written and recorded as a Dee Snider solo album before the record company insisted it be marketed as Twisted Sister (none of the band actually played on it). So this album may be the glam fluff you seem to think the rest of their discography qualifies as, but its a different artist.