Highest number of masterpieces in a row

Thy Serpent · **Posted:** Mon Dec 04, 2006 10:49 pm

stub wrote:

Pasqua wrote:

Radagast wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

The first five Megadeth and Metallica album—no diggity, no doubt.

There isn't an outright bad album among them, but So Far So Good So What and Metallica aren't even very good, never mind masterpieces.

Regarding Megadeth and Metallica, I think Metallica maybe has a THREE masterpiece sequence (ride-puppets-justice), and Megadeth FOUR (peace sells-so far-rust-countdown). To me, these seven deserve 90, 91 tops, except for Rust In Peace, of course, which deserves a 100.

Still, me thinks no one can beat Maiden with FIVE. :dio:

I'm sorry to say this, but i think you're GAY. Not that there's a problem with that, nothing personal...but not including Killers, 1st Maiden album, Kill'em All and Killing is My Business in your list of masterpieces is enough proof for me that you're gay.

But that's ok, being gay can be cool sometimes... :wink:

Maiden's first two albums were very good. But not as good as their albums from 82-88. KEA never did anything for me. I hate that album with a passion. And Killing Is My Business is good too. But I like Megadeth's later albums, RIP, CTE uptil Cryptic Writings more.

DevotedWalnut · **Posted:** Tue Dec 05, 2006 4:45 pm

Thy Serpent wrote:

stub wrote:

Pasqua wrote:

Radagast wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

The first five Megadeth and Metallica album—no diggity, no doubt.

There isn't an outright bad album among them, but So Far So Good So What and Metallica aren't even very good, never mind masterpieces.

Regarding Megadeth and Metallica, I think Metallica maybe has a THREE masterpiece sequence (ride-puppets-justice), and Megadeth FOUR (peace sells-so far-rust-countdown). To me, these seven deserve 90, 91 tops, except for Rust In Peace, of course, which deserves a 100.

Still, me thinks no one can beat Maiden with FIVE. :dio:

I'm sorry to say this, but i think you're GAY. Not that there's a problem with that, nothing personal...but not including Killers, 1st Maiden album, Kill'em All and Killing is My Business in your list of masterpieces is enough proof for me that you're gay.

But that's ok, being gay can be cool sometimes... :wink:

Maiden's first two albums were very good. But not as good as their albums from 82-88. KEA never did anything for me. I hate that album with a passion. And Killing Is My Business is good too. But I like Megadeth's later albums, RIP, CTE uptil Cryptic Writings more.

And that's why you suck. ok you dont suck, im sorry

Thy Serpent · **Posted:** Wed Dec 06, 2006 9:31 pm

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Thy Serpent wrote:

stub wrote:

Pasqua wrote:

Radagast wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

The first five Megadeth and Metallica album—no diggity, no doubt.

There isn't an outright bad album among them, but So Far So Good So What and Metallica aren't even very good, never mind masterpieces.

Regarding Megadeth and Metallica, I think Metallica maybe has a THREE masterpiece sequence (ride-puppets-justice), and Megadeth FOUR (peace sells-so far-rust-countdown). To me, these seven deserve 90, 91 tops, except for Rust In Peace, of course, which deserves a 100.

Still, me thinks no one can beat Maiden with FIVE. :dio:

I'm sorry to say this, but i think you're GAY. Not that there's a problem with that, nothing personal...but not including Killers, 1st Maiden album, Kill'em All and Killing is My Business in your list of masterpieces is enough proof for me that you're gay.

But that's ok, being gay can be cool sometimes... :wink:

Maiden's first two albums were very good. But not as good as their albums from 82-88. KEA never did anything for me. I hate that album with a passion. And Killing Is My Business is good too. But I like Megadeth's later albums, RIP, CTE uptil Cryptic Writings more.

And that's why you suck. ok you dont suck, im sorry

So, if someone's taste doesn't match yours, they suck? I happen to see this too "ok you dont suck, im sorry" Was that typed by you?

DevotedWalnut · **Posted:** Fri Dec 08, 2006 7:01 am

Thy Serpent wrote:

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Thy Serpent wrote:

stub wrote:

Pasqua wrote:

Radagast wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

The first five Megadeth and Metallica album—no diggity, no doubt.

There isn't an outright bad album among them, but So Far So Good So What and Metallica aren't even very good, never mind masterpieces.

Regarding Megadeth and Metallica, I think Metallica maybe has a THREE masterpiece sequence (ride-puppets-justice), and Megadeth FOUR (peace sells-so far-rust-countdown). To me, these seven deserve 90, 91 tops, except for Rust In Peace, of course, which deserves a 100.

Still, me thinks no one can beat Maiden with FIVE. :dio:

I'm sorry to say this, but i think you're GAY. Not that there's a problem with that, nothing personal...but not including Killers, 1st Maiden album, Kill'em All and Killing is My Business in your list of masterpieces is enough proof for me that you're gay.

But that's ok, being gay can be cool sometimes... :wink:

Maiden's first two albums were very good. But not as good as their albums from 82-88. KEA never did anything for me. I hate that album with a passion. And Killing Is My Business is good too. But I like Megadeth's later albums, RIP, CTE uptil Cryptic Writings more.

And that's why you suck. ok you dont suck, im sorry

So, if someone's taste doesn't match yours, they suck? I happen to see this too "ok you dont suck, im sorry" Was that typed by you?

Yes it was typed by me. I'm sorry, if I offended you it was just a joke.

Thy Serpent · **Posted:** Fri Dec 08, 2006 7:31 am

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Yes it was typed by me. I'm sorry, if I offended you it was just a joke.

Hey that's ok mate. I've seen this kinda comments being made in jest among other posters. Just becomes a little hard to get the message without a smiley

DevotedWalnut · **Posted:** Fri Dec 08, 2006 7:37 am

Thy Serpent wrote:

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Yes it was typed by me. I'm sorry, if I offended you it was just a joke.

Hey that's ok mate. I've seen this kinda comments being made in jest among other posters. Just becomes a little hard to get the message without a smiley

Ok well I will remember that next time.

thedirtyporthole · **Posted:** Fri Dec 08, 2006 3:05 pm

Im sure not everyone will agree but for originality and musicianship I would say Pain of Salvations first 4 albums, (Entropia, One Hour by The Concrete Lake, Remedy Lane, and The Perfect Element I), were all 90s and up rated albums. They ended the streak with Be, but "Be" was so different that I find it hard to be a disappointment.

Also, even though there are no reviews on this site or them, the two Riverside albums, (Out of Myself, Second Life Syndrome) are absolute must have albums. I would rate the first at around a 94 and the second at around a 96. Both amazing.

ganeshaRules · **Posted:** Sat Dec 09, 2006 2:15 pm

Sodom, death, maiden (7 in a row, not 5), kreator, blind guardian, savatage, metal church are all obvious choices.
Some more:

Queensyche from self titled ep to Empire. 5 in a row
Destruction, from Infernal overkill to Cracked brain (including Mad butcher EP, not including live album) 5 in a row.
Voivod, from War and Pain to Nothingface. 5 in a row.
Coroner, all discography. 5 in a row.

Holy_Terror · **Posted:** Sat Dec 09, 2006 6:36 pm

Eyesore wrote:

Radagast wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

The first five Megadeth and Metallica album—no diggity, no doubt.

There isn't an outright bad album among them, but So Far So Good So What and Metallica aren't even very good, never mind masterpieces.

You can argue So Far So Good, but the black album is a masterpiece. Maybe not to the metal purist, but there isn't a bad song on that album. Not even close.

Gah!!!

Metal Reviews

Highest number of masterpieces in a row

Who is online