derncare wrote:
I think people want to hate the Blaze era so much that they refuse to admit just how bad No Prayer for the Dying was, but I think Fear of the Dark was a pretty good album. My problems with X-Factor, besides Blaze (he's a decent enough singer, but he didn't have the range or the charisma to carry certain Maiden songs), have mostly to do with the production.
The X-Factor's songs were created around Blaze's singing style, thats why the songs as a whole went down so well. Having Bruce sing any of those X-Factor songs would not sound anywhere near as good....an example would be Bruce doing Sign Of The Cross on Rock In Rio....he didnt sound good at all. Now compare that to Blaze's live version on As Live As It Gets....just as good as the original.
But, Virtual XI was a tad different. Blaze had to sing a little differently as if the music was meant for Bruce. A good example of this would be The Clansman on Rock In Rio with Bruce singing it. A very good version of the song.
I agree with you about people wanting to hate the Blaze era so much to refuse to admit that NPFTD was rather poor for Maiden standards (boring, strained, tired effort, IMO), but i cant agree that FOTD is any better.
There are some shockers in that album (The Apparition, Fear Is The Key, Chains Of Misery), and only 4 fairly decent tracks (Be Quick Or Be Dead, Afraid To Shoot Strangers, Judas Be My Guide & Fear Of The Dark). The rest (aside from The Fugitive, which is pretty good) are just average at best.