Holy_Terror wrote:
Adveser wrote:
traptunderice wrote:
Adveser wrote:
quasi-metal, which is what I think Sabbath is too.
get the fuck out with that shit.
Sorry, I think Metal started when Priest created the image of metal and decided there would be no "hit singles" or other bullshit on the record except metal songs.
I think Sabbath was a very heavy hard rock band. Metal started with either Blue Cheer or Steppenwolf or it started later when Metal became it's own thing. I wouldn't consider Sabbath's debut the first metal under any circumstances. It was either earlier or later. Sab have absolutely no claim to that at all either way. Playing in Eb does not make one a metal band.
I mean seriously? People think Zeppelin was metal? that is a stretch at best and Sabbath didn't really become a metal band until they worked with Birch.
I think very little of the 70's was metal at all, no matter how heavy.
We aren't really talking about how heavy something is for that discussion, but if it is metal and I don't think that term could be codified until the early 0's in retrospect.
I think people that think my definition is definitive or their own is is quite stupid. It's an opinion and nothing more.
I think you're wrong about Zeppellin. While not categorically being a heavy metal band, they were playing some of the heaviest, most epic, harmonized music by the late 70's. Listen to Achilles Last Stand and tell me Led Zeppelin doesnt play heavy metal.
Well, I think there were a ton of Hair Metal bands doing metal too, but I don't consider them "Heavy Metal"
Yeah, Zeppelin, Purple and I think Rush were playing what would eventually become metal, but it just was not known as such nor marketed that way until bands like Maiden and Priest decided to take it in that direction 100%.
Hard Rock pretty much forked into three genres in the early 80's: Hair Metal, AOR (think Starship/Survivor), Heavy Metal
The main distinction is that it was all retrospective. I do list "Heavy Metal" as one of the genres for Sabbath but if only because their post-70's output was most definitely metal. If they would have retired after firing Ozzy's ass, they would have been a Hard Rock band for sure. Just like Rainbow wasn't really a metal band, close but not quite there.
More picks:
Queen: "Stone Cold Crazy" (oops, I saw it was included in the OP after writing it in)
Robin Trower - "Day of the Eagle"
Ted Nugent - "Death By Misadventure"