lizardtail wrote:
T.I.E. wrote:
Greatest Axemen :
-Robert Fripp
8)
Adrian Belew and Tony Levin are also both exceptional - I suppose anyone who gets anywhere near King Crimson has to be. Also, Steve Howe doesn't get anywhere near enough love..
edit: and Mike Oldfield! I know he doesn't immediately jump to mind, but his melodies are twice as rich as they would be if they were played by anyone else.
I agree on Howe. I love him and always get shit from people who are all too happy to pretend he wasn't awesome.
And indeed, Jeff Beck is the man. He isn't the most original songwriter around, he simply floats with the times. But he does it with skill, and a knack for great melodies, licks, and so on. He is one of the few, if not the only, legends of his time to constantly update himself with the times and stay both respectable and enjoyable.
As for Becker, he is definitely one of the few guys in the shred era that was musical and enjoyable beyond the first few minutes of "holy shit that's fast!". He and Friedman made what was easily some of the best guitar music of that period.
Vai is lame, he suffers from Chris Impellitteri disease, which is he is freaking worthless when he isn't going at breakneck speeds. Vai is probably my least favorite of the guitar virtuosos, because he composes music that is as uninteresting as any of his contemporaries without the benefit of the speed or intensity that adds to their sound. Eric Johnson has similar problems, he simply doesn't take the time to make his music interesting or his melodies memorable, with a few exceptions. People are much too quick to dismiss any technically impressive guitarist in order to sound like they are musically mature or some shit, but some of those guys were great musicians as well as technically gifted guitarists.