Metal Reviews

hello

what is your opinion on bands such as Phantom, Pig Destroyer, Circle of Dead Children or Von Goat

do you consider them extreme raw black metal or grindcore, seeing as they have influences from both ?

here is an example

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1T5KIPDwrr8

or

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGUzA4cewOU

would you say this song is black metal or grindcore ?

thanks

Dunno about Phantom, but the others are definitely grind, especially Pig Destroyer. Think you have to have a thematic setting in black metal to make you so, even if the blasting and riffs make you possibly sound a bit closer to it...

That Phantom clip sounds like grindcore, but I'm not wholly sure why you'd want to listen to it.