Do You Think Metallica Can Make A Comeback?

Thomas · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 12:20 pm

Stefan wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Load 35/100
Reload 30/100

You're soooo trOO! :rolleyes:

whats your problem?

And zad, maybe not. I never liked it, and Kill 'em all deserves it more imo.

Stefan · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 12:41 pm

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

It does. The problem with RTL is that there are two weak songs, Trapped Under Ice & Escape... Other than that, it's a near perfect album with 6 classic songs! :dio:

@ metal_xxx
I have no problem. I just thought your ratings of Load and Reload were a tad too extreme and probably a way for you to express how true a thrash fanatic you are... :wink:

Goat · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 12:51 pm

metal_xxx wrote:

Stefan wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Load 35/100
Reload 30/100

You're soooo trOO! :rolleyes:

whats your problem?

And zad, maybe not. I never liked it, and Kill 'em all deserves it more imo.

Kill 'Em All's been done!

http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=1920

I see that Show No Mercy hasn't, though. :blink:

Dago · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 2:14 pm

Stefan wrote:

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

It does. The problem with RTL is that there are two weak songs, Trapped Under Ice & Escape... Other than that, it's a near perfect album with 6 classic songs! :dio:

@ metal_xxx
I have no problem. I just thought your ratings of Load and Reload were a tad too extreme and probably a way for you to express how true a thrash fanatic you are... :wink:

Like you are going to show someone you are tr00 trashing Metallica... hehe everyone could do that...

Thomas · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:03 pm

I'm no thrash fanatic at all actually, I just don't like those albums... Not my thing. A few good songs, but nothing in particular.

Stefan · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:29 pm

Zad wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Stefan wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Load 35/100
Reload 30/100

You're soooo trOO! :rolleyes:

whats your problem?

And zad, maybe not. I never liked it, and Kill 'em all deserves it more imo.

Kill 'Em All's been done!

http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=1920

I see that Show No Mercy hasn't, though. :blink:

Makes sense.... it sucks!

Goat · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:50 pm

Stefan, you're going to DIE BY THE SWORD!

rio · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:50 pm

Stefan wrote:

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

It does. The problem with RTL is that there are two weak songs, Trapped Under Ice & Escape... Other than that, it's a near perfect album with 6 classic songs! :dio:

@ metal_xxx
I have no problem. I just thought your ratings of Load and Reload were a tad too extreme and probably a way for you to express how true a thrash fanatic you are... :wink:

NO.

NO NO NO NO NO.

ABSOLUTEMENT NON.

IMO S&M is their most underrated release, nobody really talks about it any more but every time I listen to it I love it.

St Anger does have some cringeworthy moments but also some great songs here and there, the UNknown Feeling especially.

Adveser · **Joined:** Tue Nov 13, 2007 1:26 am **Posts:** 2491

I'll put up a super-accurate rating later, but for now this is how I break it down:

Kill em all - 75
Ride the lightning - 80
Master of puppets - 100
And justice for all - 95
Metallica - 80
Load - Unknown, haven't heard the whole thing despite owning it
Re-Load - 75
St. Anger - 65

Metalhead_Bastard · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 5:51 pm

Zad wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Stefan wrote:

metal_xxx wrote:

Load 35/100
Reload 30/100

You're soooo trOO! :rolleyes:

whats your problem?

And zad, maybe not. I never liked it, and Kill 'em all deserves it more imo.

Kill 'Em All's been done!

http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=1920

I see that Show No Mercy hasn't, though. :blink:

If I log on next week to see it reviewed as an archive with a rating of 64/100 I'm gonna go and listen to Fallout Boy.

noodles · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 6:17 pm

my Metallica ratings:

Ride the Lightning - 75/100
Master of Puppets - 80/100

haven't heard any of the others

Dago · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 6:57 pm

Show No Mercy is Slayer's classic.

Antonakis · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 7:20 pm

and my approximate ratings are:

Kill 'Em All 80/100
Ride The Lightning 80/100
Master Of Puppets 95/100
...And Justice For All 90/100
Black Album 80/100
Load 70/100
Reload 75/100
St. Anger 20/100

I haven't heard S&M, garage days or other stuff. I still think Metallica can make a great comeback though. I'm almost certain it will not be a thrash comeback towards their earlier days but I believe they still have it and can create a quality modern metal/hardrock album that could rate around the 90 scale.

Stefan · **Posted:** Fri Jun 06, 2008 7:47 pm

Dago wrote:

Show No Mercy is Slayer's classic.

My favourite (well, the only one I really like actually) is South Of Heaven... :cool:

DevotedWalnut · **Posted:** Sat Jun 07, 2008 8:53 am

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

Yes it does! I was going to say, why are so many people wating it so low. The best they have are KeA and RtL.

I owuld do a list like everyone else, buts thats why im not doing it. because everyone else did.

Afro Lint · **Joined:** Sun Aug 19, 2007 2:30 am **Posts:** 1212

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

Yes it does! I was going to say, why are so many people wating it so low. The best they have are KeA and RtL.

I owuld do a list like everyone else, buts thats why im not doing it. because everyone else did.

The first 5 Metallica albums are classics.

Caligula_K · **Joined:** Mon Nov 22, 2004 8:56 pm **Posts:** 3561

Stefan wrote:

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

It does. The problem with RTL is that there are two weak songs, Trapped Under Ice & Escape... Other than that, it's a near perfect album with 6 classic songs! :dio:

:

Looooooosers! Escape is pure NWOBHM goodness, and Trapped Under Ice is as good as a song thats stolen from Exodus can be!

RTL is their best album, 95/100.

And for the rest..

Kill Em All- 90/100
Ride the Lightning- 95/100
Master of Puppets- 80/100
...And Justice For All- 85/100
Black Album- 55/100
Load- 40/100
Reload- 40/100
St. Anger- 5/100

rio · **Posted:** Sat Jun 07, 2008 1:24 pm

noodles wrote:

my Metallica ratings:

Ride the Lightning - 75/100
Master of Puppets - 80/100

haven't heard any of the others

wow you need to listeen to AJFA, maybe it's your kind of thing.

Thomas · **Posted:** Sat Jun 07, 2008 1:41 pm

Afro Lint wrote:

DevotedWalnut wrote:

Zad wrote:

Interesting how most people seem to be marking RTL down... maybe it doesn't deserve a classic after all.

Yes it does! I was going to say, why are so many people wating it so low. The best they have are KeA and RtL.

I owuld do a list like everyone else, buts thats why im not doing it. because everyone else did.

The first 5 Metallica albums are classics.

Why do you consider black album a classic?

ganeshaRules · **Posted:** Sat Jun 07, 2008 3:16 pm

The 4 first Metallica albums are classics. Escape is a hell of song, one of the most underrated of metal, and Trapped under ice is a good one.

And Black album is, imo, not a classic.

Metal Reviews

Do You Think Metallica Can Make A Comeback?

Who is online