Eyesore wrote:
This is a HIT by a mile! Personally I think The Dark Ride is a bit disappointing. A good number of the songs, I don't feel, are as good as they're capable of writing. It's not a bad album by any means, but I think Rabbit is slightly better. And it's a fucking religious album, probably the most Christian-like album they've released, so it's always fun to listen to metalheads talk about it being "dark" and not really getting it!

I'm not saying any of you are like that, but I'm sure you at least know some people who think that way.
Haha. I noticed that too. Plus, I wouldn't exactly call Mr. Torture a dark/evil song. Yeah, may be the guitars were heavier and the lyrics generally not quite as playful, but Dark Ride was certainly far from being a dark album (the title track is probably my absolute favorite Helloween song, by the way).
I noticed something similar with Anthrax's Persistence of Time. It's a very moralistic album. Most of its songs directly preach against racism, hatred, etc. And yet, metal fans always call it "dark" and "evil" just because there are no tributes to comic book heroes or rap-metal jokes on the album. Did they EVER bother actually reading the lyrics?
"I can't take it. Stop this hatred - Now!!!" ~ H8 Red
"I don't see in black and white. I see things in wrong and right" ~ Same song.
"Why the hell do you hate?" ~ Keep It In The Family
Those certainly don't sound "dark/evil" to me.