I must be the only person in the world is not all that impressed with Khan. I think his vocal tone is good, but not incredible.

I'm gonna catch some shit for saying so, but when I sing Kamelot songs, I find them a bit effortless compared to a lot of other shit. Silent Force (DC Cooper) for example is very very difficult to get down, so is stuff like Tribuzy for the insane range alone. I just don't see what warrants all this praise the guy gets. Sure the songs are good, but I don't think the guy has recorded anything any other pro singer is going to struggle with.

I think Khan, if he is writing his own notes, chooses the easiest and most familiar note progressions. Some of these singers are crazy. They will write out a 15-not progression on an acoustic guitar and woodshed it until it's clean and perfect...then work on the next line until they have something that would take anyone else probably a few days just to figure out for each song.

Fabio seems to be having an easy time with it. I seriously doubt Khan could sing most of Fabio's work from the first two VD albums.

Yeah I had a feeling you were the shithead on Blabbermouth bad mouthing Khan

That's because everyone over there is bashing Fabio, which is bullshit. Fabio is singing songs Khan can't sing even if he were there. That's really all there is to say. Chain smoking Fabio has bested Khan at his own game.

I think Roy may have "auto traumatized" himself with The Great Pandemonium. In the sense that it was too dark for his religious views and in the sense that he didn't want to sing stuff like "I spoke to God but he wasn't there" anymore. I mean just watch the video , that's pretty dark and borderline demonic

I know it sound crazy but apparently there is a religious reason behind his departure according to Thomas and very religious people tend to be affected by stuff like that and question their own views at some point. I know a guy who was once in a black metal band but then converted to Christianity to the point where he destroyed all his metal collection and cut off all links with his metal past. As i said , crazy but possible. Not saying that's why Rpy left but that's possibly a part of the reason why

I like Fabio myself but you can't compare the two since both have 2 different distinctive vocal styles.

But you bashing Khan like he's some second rated singer is so full of bullshit its not even funny.

If you think you can do better then by all means bright one go apply to fill Khan's shoes. I promise to the almighty God himself you won't even come close to filling his shoes by any means necessary.

Khan made an impression in the metal world like no other. His voice is bright,energetic and emotional. He doesn't need to wow you with high pitch wails. He does a fucking fine job with his mid range as to the testament to those who have already responded to this thread including me.

So get off his fucking nuts man. Otherwise man up and see if you can do better then him. Like I said you wouldn't have a snails chance of impressing anyone.

Don't take this personally, because unlike yourself I don't intend to belittle someone for their opinion. Don't be a hypocrite suggesting that unless you are far better than the talent you are talking about in their field, you don't have the right to an opinion. That is complete bullshit and you know it.

He is second rate. Second rate in Prog or Power metal is extremely good, among the best actually and I have only busted people's balls that wanna put him up on some untouchable pedestal that no one can replace him. Fabio and Edu seemed to not have many problems. He ain't Elvis and this isn't the Elvis Presley band.

Can't compare the two? If you can't be compared to your contemporaries what they hell can you compare? They are both Power Metal singers. That's good enough for me. Especially when people want to act like Fabio is not good enough to sing what Khan physically can't.

I'm saying as a singer who's done the material, I find Kahn to be like George Lynch is to guitar. Insanely good, but not the top of the heap.

I'd tickets for Kamelot, (they were touring Mexico some weeks ago), and I throw 'em to the garbage when I found that Fabio was coming instead of Roy... because he was feeling depressed.... what a fucking gay. And now he quits!



He might be gay, but what a fine velvet voice he had. Calling him a "second rate singer" is just stupid... really stupid. Seriously.

Karma is one of my fav power metal albums ever. I admit that I didn't like too much their last two albums, perhaps the separation was the best thing.

Khan has a fantastic voice.. When it comes to what he writes, I'm sure he's not the only one who decides how to do whatever. Anybody claiming anything else have not insight in music whatsoever, the guy can sing, like no-one else. And that's a fucking fact.