Metal Reviews :: View topic - Heavy/Prog/Power Voting Discussion Thread

This was tuff b/c I had to group Prog and Power and Heavy all in one category.

Where should I list progressive rock albums? :unsure:

metalNESS wrote:

This was tuff b/c I had to group Prog and Power and Heavy all in one category.

Hey yeah this ain't fair. Death/black/thrash all got separate voting threads but you group heavy/power/prog into one. At least do another for progressive metal. You can't expect me to list the top 5 albums from 3 genres. Is this format the same as last year ? I don't think it is otherwise I would have said something.

can't prog and prog metal be in the same category then ? :unsure:

Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies.

Stefan wrote:

can't prog and prog metal be in the same category then ? :unsure:

I think prog rock, such as Coheed and Cambria, should go in Rock/Hard Rock, just because it isn't metal. Stuff like Pagan's Mind should go in the prog metal thread.

Adveser wrote:

Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies.

I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam?

Afro Lint wrote:

Adveser wrote:

Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies.

I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam?

I don't know, I mean if it originally came out in '03, then it's not really a new album, even if the lyrics are being translated for the first time.

oops - was I wrong placing RUSH in my "prog metal" top list?

Adam wrote:

Afro Lint wrote:

Adveser wrote:

Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies.

I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam?

I don't know, I mean if it originally came out in '03, then it's not really a new album, even if the lyrics are being translated for the first time.

FINE!

Author:	Adam [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 3:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Heavy/Prog/Power Voting Discussion Thread
Please feel free to discuss voting in this thread, or ask questions about albums you are unsure of where to place. Please only discuss voting in this thread, not in the voting thread.

Author:	noodles [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:00 pm ]
Post subject:
SLOUGHFEGSLOUGHFEGSLOUGHFEGSLOUGHFEG

Author:	Ness [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:13 pm ]
Post subject:
This was tuff b/c I had to group Prog and Power and Heavy all in one category.

Author:	Stefan [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 9:32 pm ]
Post subject:
Where should I list progressive rock albums?

Author:	PyroMan [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 9:56 pm ]
Post subject:
metalNESS wrote: This was tuff b/c I had to group Prog and Power and Heavy all in one category. Hey yeah this ain't fair. Death/black/thrash all got separate voting threads but you group heavy/power/prog into one. At least do another for progressive metal. You can't expect me to list the top 5 albums from 3 genres. Is this format the same as last year ? I don't think it is otherwise I would have said something.

Metal Reviews https://www.metalreviews.com/phpBB/

Heavy/Prog/Power Voting Discussion Thread https://www.metalreviews.com/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=10501	Page 1 of 3

Author:	noodles [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 10:05 pm ]
Post subject:
Stefan wrote: Where should I list progressive rock albums? in rock forum i guess, thats where me and ness put them imo heavy/prog/power are usually hard to separate but they should have like 10 choices or smth :o

Author:	Stefan [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 10:06 pm ]
Post subject:
And prog metal here ? That doesn't make sense...

Author:	Adam [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 11:04 pm ]
Post subject:
PyroMan wrote: metalNESS wrote: This was tuff b/c I had to group Prog and Power and Heavy all in one category. Hey yeah this ain't fair. Death/black/thrash all got separate voting threads but you group heavy/power/prog into one. At least do another for progressive metal. You can't expect me to list the top 5 albums from 3 genres. Is this format the same as last year ? I don't think it is otherwise I would have said something. You are correct, my apologies. I added the prog poll. Anyone who already voted for prog albums in the first poll will need to amend their list. Sorry about that. I haven't been getting a lot of sleep lately thanks to the little one. There should be one for Heavy/Power/True and another for Prog, as it was last year. The reasoning for this is that if you split the first three out, it spreads the voting too thin. If you remember, that was the way it was done the first year, and every five minutes someone was asking if a band was Heavy, Power, or True. Death, Black, and Thrash are much easier to differentiate, and their votes are numerous, so they each get their own thread. Sorry again for all the confusion!

Author:	Stefan [ Thu Dec 13, 2007 11:29 pm ]
Post subject:
can't prog and prog metal be in the same category then ?

Author:	Adveser [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 12:47 am ]
Post subject:
Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies.

Author:	Adam [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 12:59 am ]
Post subject:
Stefan wrote: can't prog and prog metal be in the same category then ? I think prog rock, such as Coheed and Cambria, should go in Rock/Hard Rock, just because it isn't metal. Stuff like Pagan's Mind should go in the prog metal thread.

Author:	FlickoftheSwitch [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 2:48 am ]
Post subject:
oops - was I wrong placing RUSH in my "prog metal" top list?

Author:	Afro Lint [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 3:29 am ]
Post subject:
Adveser wrote: Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies. I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam?

Author:	Adam [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 3:41 am ]
Post subject:
Afro Lint wrote: Adveser wrote: Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies. I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam? I don't know, I mean if it originally came out in '03, then it's not really a new album, even if the lyrics are being translated for the first time.

Author:	Adveser [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:22 am ]
Post subject:
So, no one else heard "eye for an eye" this year. I'll have to check and make sure it wasn't resissued this year by locomotive. update: it was released originally this year, and I did'nt know Joacim cans sang on it either. (and produced) Andy laroche produced also.

Author:	unreal [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 5:24 pm ]
Post subject:
The Ocean - Precambrian should this be filed under progressive metal? is it me, or are there lots of prog albums posted in the power/heavy vote topic, will these be edited? + is axenstar - final requiem not from 2006, cause a member posted it. + can wa post ep's as well in our top? (avantasia)...

Page 1 of 3	All times are UTC + 1 hour
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	Afro Lint [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 5:42 am ]
Post subject:
Adam wrote: Afro Lint wrote: Adveser wrote: Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies. I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam? I don't know, I mean if it originally came out in '03, then it's not really a new album, even if the lyrics are being translated for the first time. FINE!

Author:	Adveser [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:20 am ]
Post subject:
FlickoftheSwitch wrote: oops - was I wrong placing RUSH in my "prog metal" top list? So , did I, but fuck it

Author:	Adam [ Fri Dec 14, 2007 2:06 pm ]
Post subject:
Afro Lint wrote: Adam wrote: Afro Lint wrote: Adveser wrote: Hey afro lint, age of nemesis' Terra Incognita came out in 2003, the 2007 version has english translated lyrics. Don't know if that qualifies. I'd say it qualifies. It's a bit different than a reissue, you know? Not sure, though. Adam? I don't know, I mean if it originally came out in '03, then it's not really a new album, even if the lyrics are being translated for the first time. FINE! I'm sure you can find another deserving candidate in your massive collection. Oh, and Octavarius, yours will have to be deleted as well.