stub wrote:
I m a little disapointed by this review.First , because you don't really describe the songs,you just say which one is your favorite(and you don't say why),which one is your less favorite,which one used to be your favorite,but you don't say much about the music(for The Rime...,you talk only about the lyrics,but you don't even mention the amazing passage in the middle of the song, with the bass solo, the strange noises of the ship,and Bruce reciting the poem).
Second,i'm disapointed because iwas expecting "Queen II" to be the classic this month(as Marty talked about a review of this one coming soon);i mean every metalhead knows every single note of Powerslave,which isn't the case with "Queen II"...unfortunately.
agreed ! this is a lousy review indeed... I was expecting to read something with historical perspective, musical content & how you feel listening to the music.... Nothing ! :evil: just some teenager babbling about the lyrics (which has never been Maiden's strongpoint with a few exceptions anyway) & chosing his favorite songs without even explaining why...
Honestly, if I had never heard this album I would have no clue how it sounds reading your review.... and that is what a bad review is all about !
EDIT : re-reading your Priest's SWOD review I would have the same complains.... maybe you're just not fit to review classics... :twisted: